ThinkTWENTY20

ThinkTWENTY20

  • HOME
  • ERIC'S BLOG
  • FORUM
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • Home | 
  • ERIC'S BLOG | 
  • When You Presume, You Make a “Pre” out of “You” and “Me”

When You Presume, You Make a “Pre” out of “You” and “Me”

on 08 October 2019

I have altered a joke made popular by the 1973 television series “The Odd Couple”, when Tony Randall, as Felix Unger, is in court and rebukes a witness by saying “never assume”. The writer for the show credited the line to a teacher in his typewriting class; a Google Books search finds an obscure 1967 reference in publications of the US National Safety Congress.

Like the problems with assuming, presumption has its challenges. I have heard the term in two different contexts related to accounting and audit.

(click on the title to read the full article)

The first usage deals with audit procedures. Confirming banking relationships, in the audit sense, was a rebuttable presumption – you had to do it unless you could provide evidence to the contrary, that it wasn’t necessary. The PCAOB’s AS 2310: The Confirmation Process still speaks about accounts receivable confirmation as a presumption. The IAASB considered the pros and cons of rebuttable presumptions back in 2004 and more recently with ISA 540 (Accounting Estimates).

The second usage deals with reliance on the auditor’s report. Although I’ve never seen it in print, I was told that – at least in the US – there is a presumption that an investor relied on the auditor’s report, and was therefore able to seek damages against an auditor if there was loss – whether or not they actually read the financial statement or read the auditor’s report. An advertorial in the Journal of Accountancy in 2015 noted, “approximately one-quarter of audit claims asserted against CPA firms in the AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program are brought by third parties.”

It is the latter presumption that was one of the items in my blog entry “Oh the Places We’ll Go!”, which mentioned a number of personal goals I had for the Extensible Business Reporting Language (XBRL). My more recent 3 September 2019 entry touched on the the area of Data Level Assurance. 

I became involved in the World Wide Web Consortium’s XML Encryption effort with the hope of using XBRL messages, digital signatures and XML Encryption so that investors could securely and anonymously register their reliance on an auditor’s opinion, and then be able to prove it in court if necessary. The world of blockchain provides even easier means to do so. Using a (free!) resource such as OriginStamp.org, an investor can anonymously capture information showing reliance on a report. When going to court, they can provide cryptographic proof of the document and time.

Why go through all of this effort? Right now, the insurance companies are paying out for anyone who says they relied on the auditor’s report. If those who prove reliance can get a lot more, and those who can’t get a lot less, the insurance companies and audit firms should wind up both being more accountable while making everyone more accountable in the process.

 

Leave a comment

    Comments

    • No comments found
    Powered by Komento
    Forum Recent Posts
    Where Will Technology Progress Take The Accounting Profession?
    Monday, 29 March 2021

    By Ricardo Rodil
    Ricardo Rodil leads the capital markets advisory services division at Crowe Macro (Brazil).

    Every time I try to understand or analyze a very complex event,  I usually try to reduce the problem to its essential elements – a sort of inverted zoom lens. I know that the devil is in the details, but I need to have some distance from them. So, I formulate extreme hypotheses, thinking about all the possible/plausible results (from 8 thru 8,000, as we say in Brazil). And, of capital importance, I know I need to keep my mind open to all possibilities. Today, I want to share with you where my latest thoughts have led me, about where and how technology is progressing and how that is transforming our lives.

    The Tele-Everything World
    Saturday, 20 March 2021

    In a non-random survey of some 915 innovators, developers, business and policy leaders, researchers and activists were asked by Pew Research to consider what life will be like in 2025 in the wake of the outbreak of the global pandemic. Overall they saw life being made worse for many people because of the spread of mis-information and authoritarianism and the fact people will become a lot more reliant on technology, which will serve to widen the economic divide.

    ThinkTWENTY20 © 2021. Privacy Policy